2016 (r-Fr.) | 8/0: Reynolds saw action in eight games as a redshirt freshman, primarily as a reserve offensive lineman and contributor on special teams. Reynolds made the move inside and contributed as a center for the Hilltoppers.
2015 (Fr.): Reynolds redshirted his first season on The Hill.
HS/Misc.: Reynolds was a Courier-Journal and Associated Press First Team All-State performer at Madisonville-North Hopkins High School, where he prepped for coach Brock Shoulders. Reynolds helped lead the Maroons to a 10-3 record and a berth in the quarterfinals of the KHSAA 4A state playoffs. Behind his work up front, the Maroons had three running backs eclipse 850 rushing yards and ran for 3,658 yards and 50 touchdowns as a team. The Maroons also eclipsed the 3,000 rushing yard mark in Reynolds’ junior season. Reynolds was also selected to play in the 2014 Best of the Bluegrass all-star game.